The article, “17 Movie and TV Characters That I Refuse To Believe Are Played By The Same Person,” highlights the transformative abilities of actors in the entertainment industry, where performers completely immerse themselves in various characters, making it hard to believe they’re played by the same individual. The piece lists 17 notable examples of actors who have portrayed vastly different characters across movies and TV shows. Below is a more detailed look at each transformation:
1. “Elvis Presley (Elvis) and Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen (Dune: Part Two) – Played by Austin Butler
Austin Butler’s transformation from the suave, soulful King of Rock ‘n’ Roll in Elvis to the menacing, ruthless Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen in Dune: Part Two showcases his versatility. These roles highlight his ability to handle both musical biopics and intense science fiction, leaving audiences amazed at how one actor could embody such contrasting characters.”
2. “Molly Weasley (Harry Potter series) and Rosie Mulligan (Mamma Mia!) – Played by Julie Walters
Julie Walters brings warmth to her roles, but her shift from the matronly, magical Molly Weasley in the Harry Potter series to the carefree, comedic Rosie Mulligan in Mamma Mia! was a delightful surprise for many fans. Walters’ ability to effortlessly switch from a magical mother figure to a carefree singer in a musical demonstrates her extensive range.”
3. “Troy Barnes (Community) and Teddy Perkins (Atlanta) – Played by Donald Glover
Donald Glover’s transition from playing the goofy, lovable Troy Barnes on Community to portraying the deeply unsettling and eerie Teddy Perkins in Atlanta was a startling display of his acting prowess. His portrayal of Perkins, with heavy makeup and a chilling demeanor, left viewers shocked that both characters were played by the same actor.”
4.”Danny Zuko (Grease) and Edna Turnblad (Hairspray) – Played by John Travolta
John Travolta has been iconic for his role as the heartthrob Danny Zuko in Grease, but his transformation into Edna Turnblad in Hairspray, a middle-aged woman, is nothing short of remarkable. Travolta’s ability to fully inhabit such drastically different characters shows his commitment to the art of acting and his versatility in comedic and musical roles.”
5. “Inigo Montoya (The Princess Bride) and Jason Gideon (Criminal Minds) – Played by Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is famous for his role as Inigo Montoya in The Princess Bride, a swashbuckling swordsman bent on revenge. Years later, he traded in his sword for a badge in Criminal Minds, where he played Jason Gideon, a serious, contemplative profiler tracking serial killers. His transformation from a whimsical fantasy character to a somber crime solver is a testament to his broad acting capabilities.””
6.”Johnny Cash (Walk the Line) and Arthur Fleck (Joker) – Played by Joaquin Phoenix
Joaquin Phoenix delivered an Oscar-winning performance as Johnny Cash in Walk the Line, a role that portrayed the country legend’s highs and lows. Years later, he gave another Oscar-winning performance as the deranged Arthur Fleck in Joker, a chilling portrayal of a man’s descent into madness. Phoenix’s ability to convincingly inhabit two characters with such emotional depth shows why he’s one of the most respected actors in the industry.”
7.”Caesar Flickerman (The Hunger Games) and George Harvey (The Lovely Bones) – Played by Stanley Tucci
Stanley Tucci often surprises audiences with his range. He plays the eccentric, flamboyant host Caesar Flickerman in The Hunger Games with ease, but his unsettling portrayal of serial killer George Harvey in The Lovely Bones is disturbingly chilling. Tucci’s ability to shift from campy to creepy highlights his skill in completely disappearing into his roles.”
8.”Dianna (Trainwreck) and the White Witch (The Chronicles of Narnia) – Played by Tilda Swinton
Tilda Swinton’s versatility knows no bounds. She’s able to move effortlessly between modern-day comedic roles, such as her appearance as Dianna in Trainwreck, and fantastical, larger-than-life characters like the White Witch in The Chronicles of Narnia. Swinton’s ethereal quality and acting ability make her one of the most compelling actors in any genre.”
9.”Kate McCallister (Home Alone) and Moira Rose (Schitt’s Creek) – Played by Catherine O’Hara
Catherine O’Hara has a knack for comedy, but her transformation from the frantic mother Kate McCallister in Home Alone to the fabulously eccentric Moira Rose in Schitt’s Creek was a comedic masterclass. O’Hara’s ability to create such different characters, with Moira’s outrageous personality and quirky charm, solidifies her place as a comedic legend.”
10.”Walter White (Breaking Bad) and Hal (Malcolm in the Middle) – Played by Bryan Cranston
Bryan Cranston is perhaps best known for his role as Walter White, the high school chemistry teacher turned drug kingpin in Breaking Bad. However, before he was Walter, he was Hal, the bumbling, lovable dad on Malcolm in the Middle. Cranston’s shift from comedy to intense drama left many viewers in awe of his range.”
11.”Penguin (The Batman) and Bobby Pellit (Horrible Bosses) – Played by Colin Farrell
Colin Farrell underwent a dramatic transformation to play Penguin in The Batman, a role that required extensive prosthetics to make him nearly unrecognizable. In contrast, his comedic performance as Bobby Pellit in Horrible Bosses was a far cry from the dark, gritty world of Gotham. Farrell’s ability to tackle both serious and humorous roles shows his dynamic range.”
13.”Cinderella (Cinderella) and Pamela Anderson (Pam & Tommy) – Played by Lily James
Lily James captured hearts as the sweet and innocent Cinderella in Disney’s live-action remake, but she stunned audiences with her transformation into Pamela Anderson for the series Pam & Tommy. James’ ability to portray both a fairytale princess and a controversial Hollywood icon proves her acting chops are impressive.”
14.”Trevor Reznik (The Machinist) and Dick Cheney (Vice) – Played by Christian Bale
Christian Bale is famous for his physical transformations, and his performances in The Machinist as Trevor Reznik, a dangerously thin insomniac, and Dick Cheney in Vice, where he gained significant weight, are extreme examples of his commitment. Bale’s ability to transform his body and mind for roles is unparalleled in Hollywood.”
15.”Barbie (Barbie) and Queen Elizabeth I (Mary Queen of Scots) – Played by Margot Robbie
Margot Robbie’s range is apparent in her portrayal of Barbie, the bubbly, fashionable doll in Barbie, and her historical turn as Queen Elizabeth I in Mary Queen of Scots. Robbie’s ability to move between such different characters showcases her versatility.”
16.”Charles Miner (The Office) and McCavity (Cats) – Played by Idris Elba
Idris Elba surprised audiences by playing two drastically different characters: the straight-laced Charles Miner on The Office and the villainous McCavity in Cats. His transformation into a CGI-enhanced feline character was a shock to many fans of his work.”
17.”Baron Vladimir Harkonnen (Dune) and Bill Anderson (Mamma Mia!) – Played by Stellan Skarsgård
Stellan Skarsgård is unrecognizable as the grotesque Baron Vladimir Harkonnen in Dune, yet he also plays the charming Bill Anderson in Mamma Mia! with ease. His drastic physical transformations in these roles show his dedication and skill.”